[1].2502201410189.jpg)
If you’ve been involved in a dog bite incident, it’s natural to wonder who’s responsible for the harm caused. Most people think that the dog owner is automatically at fault, and while this is often true, it’s not always the case. Some incidents involve a shared responsibility between the dog owner and others involved.
Understanding how liability works in dog bite cases can help you take appropriate steps to protect your rights—whether you’ve been bitten or your dog was involved in an incident.
The Basics of Liability in Dog Bite Cases
Dog bite cases are typically governed by state-specific laws, many of which place responsibility on the dog owner. These laws generally fall into one of two categories:
1. Strict Liability Laws
States with strict liability laws hold dog owners responsible for bites, even if the dog has no history of aggression and the owner took reasonable precautions. If a bite occurs, the owner is liable simply because they own the dog.
2. One-Bite Laws
Some states follow the “one-bite rule,” giving dog owners more leeway. Under this rule, an owner may only be held liable if they knew or should have known that their dog was dangerous—such as if the dog previously bit someone.
However, even in strict liability states, there are situations where the concept of shared responsibility, or comparative negligence, is involved.
What Is Shared Responsibility?
“Shared responsibility” means that both the dog owner and the injured person (or another third party) may share liability for a dog bite. For instance, if the injured person provoked the dog or disregarded warning signs, they may be partially to blame for the incident.
Here are some factors that can influence shared responsibility in dog bite cases:
1. Provocation
Was the dog provoked before biting someone? Actions like teasing, hitting, or attempting to take food or toys from a dog can be considered provocation. If the injured person provoked the dog, their liability may be reduced.
2. Trespassing
If a person is bitten while unlawfully trespassing on the dog owner’s property, the owner may not be fully liable. Many states reduce or remove liability for bites that occur when the victim is somewhere they’re not legally allowed to be.
3. Negligence by a Third Party
Someone other than the dog owner may be partially responsible for a bite. For example, if a dog walker didn’t leash the dog properly or left the animal unsupervised, they could share fault for the incident.
4. Failure to Follow Guidelines
If the injured person ignored posted warnings (like “Beware of Dog” signs) or failed to heed verbal instructions from the owner, they may be partially at fault.
5. Children and Dog Bites
When children are involved, the situation becomes more nuanced. Courts typically expect adults to take reasonable precautions to protect children from harm, but owners may still be held partially responsible if they failed to keep aggressive dogs away from unsupervised kids.
What Happens When Fault Is Shared?
Many states operate under comparative negligence rules for personal injury cases, including dog bites. Under comparative negligence, the amount of compensation awarded to the injured person can be reduced based on their share of fault. For example:
- If a court finds the dog owner 80% responsible and the injured person 20% responsible, the injured person’s compensation might be reduced by 20%.
- Some states follow a modified comparative negligence rule, meaning the injured person can only recover damages if their share of fault is below a certain threshold (e.g., 50%).
Understanding these nuances underlines why dog bite cases aren’t always black and white.
What to Do If You’re Injured in a Dog Bite Incident
If you’ve been bitten, acting quickly to preserve your health and legal rights is important. Here’s what you can do:
1. Seek Medical Attention
Dog bites can lead to serious infections, including rabies or tetanus. Even minor bites should be cleaned, treated, and evaluated by a medical professional.
2. Gather Information
If possible, obtain the dog owner’s contact information and details about the dog (such as its vaccination history). Look for any witnesses who saw the incident and can provide statements.
3. Document the Scene
Take photos of your injuries, the location where the bite occurred, and any relevant signage or conditions, like whether the dog was leashed. These can serve as critical evidence.
4. Consult an Attorney
Dog bite laws can be complex, especially in cases involving shared responsibility. A personal injury attorney can help you determine whether you have a case and guide you through the process of seeking compensation.
5. Contact Animal Control or Local Authorities
Reporting the bite is often required by law. Animal control can investigate the incident, quarantine the dog if necessary, and keep a record of the case.
What If Your Dog Is Accused of Biting Someone?
Dog owners often feel fear and guilt when their pet is involved in a biting incident. However, you still have legal rights. If your dog is accused of causing harm, these steps can help protect your interests:
- Provide Proof of Vaccination: Proof that your dog is up-to-date on vaccinations can help mitigate concerns about infections like rabies.
- Keep Communication Open: Cooperate with local authorities or animal control as they investigate.
- Consult an Attorney: If a personal injury claim is brought against you, legal representation is essential for defending your rights and handling the case fairly.
- Determine Contributing Factors: Note any potential provocation or negligence that may have contributed to the incident.
Sacramento Dog Bite Attorney
As dog bite cases continue to pose challenges for both dog owners and victims, understanding the complexities of liability and shared responsibility is essential. At Del Rio & Caraway, P.C., we are committed to providing expert legal guidance and support for those affected by dog bite incidents in Sacramento, CA. Whether you are a dog owner seeking to understand your rights and responsibilities or a victim pursuing compensation, our experienced legal team is here to help. Contact us today at (916) 229-6755 to learn more about how we can assist you in navigating the legal landscape and achieving a fair resolution.